Sunita Paul Continues To Plagiarize

It appears that “Sunita Paul” cannot help herself. Even after facing charges of plagiarism, she continues to plagiarize.

According to “Sunita Paul”‘s bio on American Chronicle, she is “considered as an expert of South Asian affairs, counter-terrorism and international relations.” However, when writing about militants in Bangladesh she plagiarizes published and copyrighted articles from Bangladesh’s leading English language newspaper, The Daily Star. There is of course irony in her stealing copyrighted content from The Daily Star and claiming it for her own because she has attacked The Daily Star as “evil” in her published work.

Now, to the latest case of brazen plagiarism from “Sunita Paul”. In an article published today on the American Chronicle entitled “Silent rise of Hizb Ut Towhid”, she plagiarized massively from two Daily Star articles. Almost the entire article is plagiarized, without any attribution, from these two articles. It is a stunning example of plagiarism.

The two articles from the Daily Star that she plagiarized from are from Daily Star’s series of investigative articles examining militant groups in Bangladesh. The first article, published on August 28, 2005, was written by Zayadul Ahsan and is entitled “Inside the Militant Groups-7: Profiles show them interlinked”. The second article, published on October 26, 2008, was written by Julfikar Ali Manik and Shariful Islam and is entitled “Tackling militancy gets tough for policy”. She plagiarized at least 5 paragraphs from the 2005 Daily Star article and 14 paragraphs from the 2008 Daily Star article.

To illustrate the plagiarism, take a look at the following three paragraphs from “Sunita Paul”‘s article from today:

The HuT chief, who left Bangladesh after the independence and returned in the ’80s, published a book titled “This Islam is not at all Islam” in March 1996, which the government banned on May 10, 1998. … Besides, there are several leaflets and booklets on the HuT ideologies and objective. Followers of HuT do not believe in democracy and traditional government system.

HuT activists use iron hammer and tobacco dust when they attack. They used a hammer to kill one Abdul Malek in Pagla Bazar in Fatulla, Narayangaj on September 26, 2003 when local devotees protested the HuT activities. Followers of this extremist group term Azan as “bark of dog” and do not say prayers in mosques. They consider Islamic greetings or Salaam as “bad practice”.

Mahbub Ali, Kushtia district HT ameer, has been working along with 40/50 activists. Sohrab Hossain Khan of Sakukuthi village in Gouranadi upazila of Barisal, an absconding accused of a murder case, has also been leading HT activities from hideouts.

Now, look at the original 5 paragraphs from the 2005 Daily Star article:

The HT chief, who left the country after the independence and returned in the ’80s, published a book titled “This Islam is not at all Islam” in March 1996, which the government banned on May 10, 1998. Ponni challenged the ban but the matter is yet to be resolved.

He also published some booklets and leaflets on HT ideologies and objectives. His followers do not believe in traditional government system.

The HT activists use iron hammer and gul (tobacco dust) when they attack. They used a hammer to kill one Abdul Malek in Pagla Bazar in Fatulla, Narayangaj on September 26, 2003 when local devotees protested the HT activities.

HT followers term ajan “barking of dog” and do not say their prayers at mosques. They never exchange salam (Islamic greetings).

Mahbub Ali, Kushtia district HT ameer, has been working along with 40/50 activists. Sohrab Hossain Khan of Sakukuthi village in Gouranadi upazila of Barisal, an absconding accused of a murder case, has also been leading HT activities from hideouts.

The paragraphs are lifted wholesale from the 2005 Daily Star article.

The plagiarism from the 2008 Daily Star article is even more blatant. “Sunita Paul” lifted, nearly intact, the last 14 paragraphs from the Daily Star article. To illustrate, I will show the first few plagiarized paragraphs below. The reader can examine the articles to see the totality of the plagiarism.

In her April 14 article, “Sunita Paul” writes:

For the last few years Hizb Ut Towhid has been carrying out secret operations in the name of ‘dawat’ in different parts of the country, especially in the southern region. In some cases Bangladeshi law enforcing agencies also arrested some activists of different Islamic organizations during their suspicious activities.

For instance, law enforcers arrested a few Hizb Ut Towhid activists in Bhola in September 2008 for their suspicious movement.

Commenting on HuT, an officer of Bangladesh Police said, “We’re closely monitoring their activities. The nature of their activities in Bhola suggests the organization might have some activities similar to those of banned militant organizations.”

He said the outfit seems suspicious as Hizb Ut Towhid’s activities have similarity with the activities and groundwork of banned militant organizations.

Now, examine the paragraphs from the 2008 Daily Star article that she plagiarized from:

For the last few years Hizb-ut Towhid has been carrying out secret operations in the name of ‘dawat’ in different parts of the country, especially in the southern region.

In some cases police also arrested some activists of different Islamic organisations during their suspicious activities.

For instance, law enforcers arrested a few Hizb-ut Towhid activists in Bhola in early September for their suspicious movement.

Superintendent of Police of Bhola GM Azizur Rahman told The Daily Star over phone that Hizb-ut Towhid has recently started its activities in the district.

“We’re closely monitoring their activities. The nature of their activities in Bhola suggests the organisation might have some activities similar to those of banned militant organisations,” Azizur observed.

He said the outfit seems suspicious as Hizb-ut Towhid’s activities have similarity with the activities and groundwork of banned militant organisations.

As you can see, the plagiarism is clear.

It is quite stunning that “Sunita Paul” continues to plagiarize even after being exposed on multiple cases of plagiarism. She continues to steal other people’s work. She is trying to claim to be an “expert” by stealing investigative work done by hard working journalists and claiming the work as her own. That is dishonest. That is fraudulent.

As Shada Kalo pointed out in his post, “Sunita Paul” claims she does not plagiarize and has never violated copyright. It is clear now, that in addition to being a plagiarist, she is a liar.

UPDATE The article on American Chronicle has now been deleted. It is still available on Google cache. The website ModernGhana.com (of all places) is also still hosting this article.

This entry was posted in Bangladesh, Media and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

48 Responses to Sunita Paul Continues To Plagiarize

  1. Ingrid says:

    she might not be a liar but just very much in denial!! Naturally, when people lie, they start to believe themselves or their justifications for them. And hers, who knows what her motivation is? It sounds deeply psychological rather than cold blooded plagiarism. If you keep denying than, it goes on and on and on. And here I was in the not so distant past paranoid that I hadn’t given credit enough on my wee humble blog..tssa..

  2. Bill Maher says:

    “It appears that “Sunita Paul” cannot help herself. Even after facing charges of plagiarism, she continues to plagiarize.”

    Now we can see who is condeming Sunita Paul for doing the right thing? Of course, you all Awami-Gov’t official and supporter charging her with “Plagiarism”. Where were you when she wrote all the stories about the part BNP Gov’t.Then she was your HERO.

    How much do you know about Mr. Farook Khan? Do you know Shekh Hasina made him Commerce Minister, so he can help her son(Sajib Wazed JOy)and daughter (Putul) how had to leave USA for…..
    to bring money from Bangladesh. What expreience he has that qualify him to become CM for Bangladesh? He is not even the CEO of his family Company “Summit Group” ?
    His younger Brother wife who won’s “F&N” he was convicted for briving Shekh Hasina is now on moves doing business again in Bangladesh. Hasina’s Son is a family friend of Faruk Khan’s in the USA and also in the Bangladesh.

    Only 3 days off of U_TUBE !? There will be more time out in the future as the Shekh Hasina’s Gov’t please . Becasue, Shekh Hasina
    without any proper bait for the business already autherize her son Joy to do networking/mobile phone business in Bangladesh.

    Watch out, who are you going after. Just know the truth before you called some one Lair.
    We all find out how many million dollars BNP’ Gov’t took from Bangladeshi people. Time will tell you about Shekh Hasina’r Gov’t too ! If you know about USA I am sure you should know about FBI, and IRS.

    Wish you all the luck

    • Mash says:

      “Bill Maher”, if “Sunita Paul” stopped plagiarizing other people’s work, people would stop calling her a plagiarist. As it is, she is plagiarizing. If you consider plagiarizing doing the “right thing”, I guess that is your right. Most people would, I suspect, disagree with you.

      I am pretty sure I have never considered “Sunita Paul” a “hero”. I make it a practice to not claim plagiarists or propagandists to be my heroes.

      Also, I am confused by your last paragraph. Please clarify.

  3. here’s some more:

    1. http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/97324 – Paras 2-8 are copied from here (including the typo in para 4): http://www.independent-bangladesh.com/2009040510809/country/bcl-central-leaders-resign-en-masse.html. the rest is a (cited) copy paste of a daily star editorial.

    2. http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/97352 – paras 2-4 are from here (with all typos intact): http://www.breakingnewsonline.net/2009/04/india-tv-opinion-poll-bjp-to-emerge-as.html. a lot more is from here: http://www.ummid.com/general_elections_2009/bjp_appeases_muslims.htm. some more from: http://www.indiadaily.com/editorial/2489.asp. and the rest is again from an op ed in the daily star.

    3. http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/58898 – a large part from here: http://tokyo.usembassy.gov/e/p/tp-20080123-02.html

    and all that just through a google search!

  4. zafa says:

    Bill (you are no Maher),

    Your rambling is a bit difficult to make sense of. Ok, I’ll be honest it is a lot difficult to make sense of.
    But I can see why you are having a heart burn over exposing this liar-cheat-plagiarist-fraud pretending to be one Sunita Paul. Because just like (s)he, you make your own assertion based on no facts what so ever.
    You are using an old formula used by typical low info partisans in Bangladesh.
    It goes like this – if a person is criticizing someone who is criticizing BNP, then that person is “most definitely” a staunch supporter of BNP. And the role reverses when you replace BNP with AL.
    I’ve never met Mash (the owner of this blog) and I don’t know if he’s adhered to any political party. But I have been reading his blog post for quite a while. Nowhere in his blog posts has there been any indication of his bias towards any political party – BNP or AL.

    When this low-life named Sunita P was writing in Asia Tribune 3 years ago and making grave accusations of millions dollars of being looted by former prime minister Zia’s sons, the logical readership of deshi blogs didn’t make much of it. Some tried to contact Sunita Paul via emails to ask about her sources that were never returned. Mash never mentioned in any of his/her writing simply because Mash adheres to only facts and analysis.

  5. M H says:

    @ Ingrid,

    Sunita Paul may suffer psychological issues, but she is one of the very few who has the guts to “say it like it is”. Her airing of “dirty laundry” is why Bangladeshi bloggers are up in arms against her.

    Most Bangladeshi bloggers have not come to grips as to what democracy means for Bangladesh. Democracy in Bangladesh is nothing more than criminal mafia organizations and criminals operating legally under cover of political parties and politicians. Many of these “politicians” are not only criminally corrupt, they’re serial murderers and mass murderers.

    The massive welfare funds foreigners send to Bangladesh only exacerbates the current instability. A cabinet minister in the current govt. is on record of taking a position AGAINST self sustainable food production! His reason being if Bangladesh were self sustainable in food, there would be no foreign currency sent as foreign aid ( and hence the lost opportunity to dip into these funds to enrich himself )

    The only reason Bangladesh hasn’t gone the way of Somalia is because of the dedicated work of a few good individuals like Dr. Yunnus and grass roots organizations such as Grameen and BRAC. Their dedication to help the poor has enabled them to negotiate the treacherous political waters called Bangladesh politics. The term “Bangladesh Paradox” was coined to explain this grass roots success.

    Instead of harping on Sunita Paul, these bloggers best spend their time creating serious dialouge on how to reform Bangladesh politics.

  6. Journey2Infinitive says:

    MH,

    “Sunita Paul may suffer psychological issues, but she is one of the very few who has the guts to “say it like it”

    Can you prove It? Do you have concrete Evidence. Or Is it your assumption and her hypothesis?

    Now
    “A cabinet minister in the current govt. is on record of taking a position AGAINST self sustainable food production! His reason being if Bangladesh were self sustainable in food, there would be no foreign currency sent as foreign aid ( and hence the lost opportunity to dip into these funds to enrich himself )”

    Ans: Can you tell his name please? How can you know so much information ? Are you there to bribe?

  7. M H says:

    @Journey2Infinitive

    You don’t have to visit the moon personally to get the idea the moon is round.

    Everything I wrote is widely known amongst Foreign embassy intelligentsia inside Bangladesh and the local Bangladesh Elite. There is a good reason foreign democracies supported the recent dictatorial military rule of the Bangladesh care taker govt.

    As for your retort …. “Are you there to bribe?”. Please don’t be disingenuous. There is a reason Bangladesh ranked #1 in corruption for several years in a row. Anyone from Bangladesh who ventures to ask such as question lacks any semblance credibility. Your time is better spent in creating dialogue on how to fix your broken country than in arguing what everyone in the world knows for fact.

  8. Journey2Infinitive says:

    MH,

    Your comment does not make any sense. By the way you can see

    Moon is round But Fact is that You can’t get any information about the moon without voyaging there. Other wise Apollo 11 was never sent to moon and every Tom, Dick and Harry could start to discuss about Astronomy and I am sorry to say your blanket comments are not more than that. Now why don’t you oil your own machine? This is not your own business what I will do about my country. See every one of us can say white to white and gray to gray. but some of you guys even don’t have minimum courage and simply speaking

    about lots of conjunctions (if,but and may be) and love to take the name of the form of MR X , Y and Z( not actual name)

    I can say It is the biggest Moral bankruptcy of yourself.

    So Don’t make Speculative comments. If You do have concrete proof Just speak on the base of that.

    And one last advice for you ” Don’t try to hide or insult your Nationality.”

  9. dhumrojal says:

    I don’t find any reason to attack Ms Sunita Paul bcz she just copied ur views. I guess 4 posts on the same issue are just too much. We expect your investigative articles instead of running after others.
    DJ

    • Mash says:

      I think I might do a few more posts exposing this fraud, propagandist, plagiarist and conspiracy theorist. It is “Sunita Paul” who has run after others and has spent quite a lot of ink spreading false propaganda about Bangladesh over a number of years. What I consider “too much” is the unchecked propaganda and anti-Bangladesh vitriol that “Sunita Paul” has been publishing.

      Because of my posts and articles by others finally exposing this fraud, American Chronicle has begun to remove her malicious propaganda. Already a number of plagiarized articles and the article that was an ad hominem attack on me has been removed. As more of her articles are shown to be plagiarized (and many are), they will also be deleted.

      Besides, many news outlets and the vast majority of my readers disagree with you. Currently both UCLA’s AsiaMedia and UK’s Sky News is featuring the op-ed I wrote about “Sunita Paul” in the Daily Star. So, clearly, this issue has some resonance.

    • Journey2Infinitive says:

      Dhumrojal,

      Don’t you know the basics of Copy Right? It is a big crime to copy some thing without the permission of the original author. It seems you like to create Dhurmrojal intentionally.

      Investigative report? what type of investigation for which Incident? Can you read the whole Blog properly? There is no vice to tell a liar to liar. Try to accept the truth Mr Corporal.

  10. M H says:

    @Journey2Infinitive

    You continually revert to criticizing anyone who makes an attempt to shine a light on Bangladesh’s core problem of institutionalized corruption. The only cure for the Roach Motel known as Bangladesh, is to create transparency and shine a light on the roaches that run the country.

    If humanity had to visit every star to make sure each star exists and visit every planet to verify its orbit, humanity would be stuck in the dark ages like Bangladesh. Hidden natural order and its laws have been discovered by extrapolating logical conclusions from physical observations. The Greeks navigated the high seas using knowledge derived from this process of (astronomical) observation. They did not have to visit the moon physically to observe that it is indeed round.

    Your comments are par for the course for Bangladesh elite and its political and business class. If anyone criticizes the corruption and ineptitude of your ruling class, you change the subject matter, attack the messenger and turn a blind eye to the moral and intellectual rot inside Bangladesh. The intellectual dishonesty amongst the Bangladesh elite is puzzling. Is it because most of your families make or made their money from the Bribe culture? It is difficult to believe all of you can be intellectually vacuous, morally corrupt and ethically challenged like Bangladesh politicians.

    It’s high time all of you focused your resources discussing the real issues challenging your country rather than attacking those who attempt to raise a dialog on what are the root cause of your problems. Attacking Mrs. Paul doesn’t solve any of your deep rooted societal problems.

  11. Journey2Infinitive says:

    MH,

    why are you insulting your own Intelligence? See It is bit funny that you have brought the reference of Planet. According to you all scientists are monitoring Planet by open eye only. Other wise Hubble Telescope was never discovered…….. ROFL.
    Your example is Just compare to this. You may tell tomorrow yes there is human life of the planet of Proxima Centauri with out any instrumental evidence. As whole matter is subject to Judiciary I should not comment but Sunita Paul’s dishonesty and lie are not even compared with any fiction. He /she is a serial liar.

    As I mentioned it is the subject of investigation But even 4% people won’t trust AL and India are involved in the Pilkhana Incident. It is common Pakistani culture to blame other for the own crime.
    After killing people in foreign Soil to deny the whole incident and then start to blame the same country where it is bombed. But such type of serial lies can’t last many days. Pakistan is the biggest example of that. Even they have lost the status of Host in world cup Cricket. Now Pakistani Ex Cricketers are blaming India, Sri lanka and Bangladesh. But Same Pakistani Cricketers did not have any answers while Lankan Cricketers were attacked, one of the finest coaches of Cricket history than Bob ulmer was murdered. We Bangladeshi Family has culture, Tradition. I am sorry to say In maximum Criminal cases of USA and Europe one Pakistani is Involved.

    Now your this blanket comment

    “most of your families make or made their money from the Bribe culture? It is difficult to believe all of you can be intellectually vacuous, morally corrupt and ethically challenged like Bangladesh politicians.”

    Ans: Really , Can you prove it and do you have any telescope with you.

    As I mentioned Make correct your fact and Figure . come with proper data and all then you will be qualified for the debate. Basically I am not scared like people like you or Sunita Paul. As I mentioned whole world know what Sunita paul and her type of people are. what ever false information and lie you bring on table you negative credibility will not be upgraded even to Zero.

  12. MBI Munshi says:

    I don’t think that Sunita Paul can be properly described as anti-Bangladesh. She seems to be more anti-AL and anti-Indian neither of which can be truly equated with being anti-Bangladesh. On most occasions AL is anti-Bangladesh and the Indians are inimical to Bangladesh. It is the fact that Sunita has exposed AL and Indian lies which has caused most outrage amongst our intellectually corrupt elite.

    • Mash says:

      What part of the following passage from Sunita Paul do you not find anti-Bangladesh?:

      Bangladesh, although demanding to be a moderate Muslim nation, is in reality a notorious Jew hater and anti West and anti American nation…people of Bangladesh in general are West and US haters and the only reason for them for sending their children to these countries are for mere money making.

      Can we raise a plain question as to whether the Jewish business communities and friends of Israel like United States should patronize Dhaka economically to sharpen and strengthen their anti Semitic and anti US sentiments?”

      You, MBI Munshi, are a broken record.

      I am really enjoying your comments and the accompanying dash of hubris. I thoroughly enjoyed this comment you posted on Shadakalo’s blog recently in response to another commenter:

      If that is the quality of your response then it is no wonder you think Doc Strange Love, Shada Kalo and Third World View provide quality material. They merely provide opinions but with what qualifications, background or experience. They spout the same carp over and over again. Where do you see the quality. You simply do not have the education to know what quality is.

      And liked this one even better:

      No you are wrong. I present my ideas on the basis of facts. In my books I use thousands of facts and references to back up my conclusions. I have done 10 years of research on regional issues. I have worked 3 years in counter-terrorism and national security. Apart from this I am a lawyer, teacher and banker. My family has been part of South Asian politics for the last 80 years. I doubt that Shadakalo,, Doctstrangelove or Third World View is anywhere near my education, experience or knowledge on these issues. They do not deal in facts but mere opinions based on their own slanted prejudices and borrowed ideas. There is nothing original about them. As I said you do not have the education or background to discern what is quality and what is crap.

      You sir are a piece of work. I am beginning to feel a little sorry for your cry for attention and because these other commenters are picking on you. I am also beginning to see why other commenters don’t take you seriously enough to engage you in sober discussion.

  13. Vidyasagar says:

    Oh dear god, this Bilai Munshi chum is so pathetic, I have now started feeling really sorry for him. I wonder why such a genius like him now trolls around different blogs in his ever more pathetic attention seeking campaign.

    Mash, I think what Mr. Munshi is really pissed about has nothing to do with Sunita P or India or AL. His aim is to piss other people off so that someone pays some attention to him. He really does not want a sober discussion anyway… jumping like a lost dog, crying for attention in the very blogs he so very despises, begging for a small piece of bone.

    Frankly, Mr. Bilai Munshi, I hear your pain but you need to figure out some other ways of trying to be Mr. Big. Fact is, no one ever heard of you, no one cares what a genius you are and if you continue to be such an annoyance in the blogsphere, you will be forever ignored. Go get your bone somewhere else.

  14. MBI Munshi says:

    I think the word sad and pathetic best describes my detractors here and on the other blog. It is because you are all incapable of sober discussion that you have to resort to light weight personal remarks and are unqualified to do anything more substantive. Sunita Paul I think has come around from her former opinions on Bangladesh and her distaste for Indian dalals is quite refreshing. These people have for the last decade have had discussion going all their way but there is now a pro-Bangladesh stream opposed to intellectual frauds like this Mash person who has an extremely high opinion of himself. Just because he has a blog he thinks he is an expert on everything under the sun. What a pathetic excuse for a human being that his only success in life is writing a blog. LOL ………. Oh I can’t stop laughing. You are in fact creepy and sad.

    • Mash says:

      Just when I think you are tapped out, you outdo yourself. Normally, I don’t feed trolls too much, but you are a special one. I am a little conflicted though. I am caught between pity and the desire to gawk at this trainwreck.

      I feel pity because you may be the most clueless person who’s commented on this blog. On the other hand, this is sort of like watching one of those reality shows where you know the guy who is about to perform is going to fail magnificently – so you can’t turn away.

      Of course I am obliging you by giving you the attention you crave – even though none of these comments have anything to do with the content of the post. I can’t promise it will last though. Sooner or later I am likely to get bored with this comment thread.

      • Journey2Infinitive says:

        I am already bored on Moha Monishi Munshi.so I will wait for his next comedy in any blog. Till then Ta ta.

  15. Vidyasagar says:

    Munshi… here… le… le… take the bone… now …. shooo…!

  16. Journey2Infinitive says:

    Oh Munshi,

    How much experience do you have of Laughing? 100 years?

  17. MBI Munshi says:

    The inanity of your remarks Mash and Journey2Infinitive simply proves my point that you are mere light weight thinkers of little substance whose only success in life is writing a blog. Your strongest argument against me is a stupid personal comment. Neither of you have the wit or intelligence to do anything more. Really pathetic and Oh I am still laughing ………

    • Mash says:

      MBI Munshi, you have no argument. Your goal is to make yourself sound important. No one give a crap about you. they just like making fun of you. Dont be so taken up with your intellectual powers. From the level of comments, its quite clear you are a idiot.

      Like a “beheya”, you keep coming back for more.

  18. banglababa says:

    This MBI Munshi guy is a heavy contributor to Pakistani military forum http://www.defence.forums. Where he plays the champion defender of his beloved Pakistani cause. The amount of anti Hindu/India venom thathe spews out in that forum is simply disturbing for any self respecting Bangladeshi.. Surely he is an embarrassment to all sane Bangladeshi.

  19. banglababa says:

    sorry the url is http://www.defence.pk/forums/ ..do check it out to figure out this insane clown called MBI Munsi.

  20. Between the Devil and the Deep Sea says:

    His Pakistan Defense is facing heard time against Tailban. They need Munshi to save their Bolved Pakistant. hahaha

  21. Between the Devil and the Deep Sea says:

    His Pakistan Defense is facing heard time against Tailban. They need Munshi to save their Belvoed Pakistan. hahaha

  22. MBI Munshi says:

    There are dozens of Bangladeshi members of the Pakistan Defense Forum and hundreds of Indian members there also. It is the biggest forum of its kind on the internet. India fought 4 wars with Pakistan but there are still hundreds of Indian members of PDF whose loyalty is never questioned. Typical pro-Indian Bangladeshis however continue to display their ignorance and utter lack of intelligence by questioning me for being a member of PDF. They are a disgrace to Bangladesh for doing so since they never question the Indian stranglehold of Bangladesh. They are intellectually dishonest and cowards because they are prepared to keep us slaves of India and their proxy the Awami League party. We must become free form India and this is our real war of independence. According to most elite Indians we are not even humans and they can kill and mistreat us like animals. Look at what happened at Pilkhana which was a RAW conspiracy. Look at what the Rakkhi Bahini did and this was also a RAW trained outfit. Even the Mujib Bahini which was a RAW trained group that committed atrocities in 1971 which was subsequently blamed on the Pakistan army. There is a clear trend from 1971 to the present of Indian atrocities on Bangladesh but not a word from these ‘renowned’ bloggers who are merely Indian stooges and paid dogs.

    • Mash says:

      Listen to yourself!

      You write “most elite Indians we are not even humans and they can kill and mistreat us like animals”. What the fuck is wrong with you? Do you not realize that in the 1971 genocide the Pakistani army and their Islamist collaborators did kill us and mistreat us like animals?!?

      Your psychosis leads from zero to namecalling. Get some serious help!

      (and no, I am not going to rehash the history of the 1971 genocide with you here. If you dont know it, or if you deny it, stay in your own ignorant bubble.)

      Go back to the Pakistan Defense Forum that you seem to be so proud of. Maybe you and your fellow Pakistan Army enthusiasts can spend some time searching for those RAW agents under your bed.

    • Janisa says:

      The purchases I make are entirely based on these arctiels.

  23. Between the Devil and the Deep Sea says:

    Munshi

    I wished to tell you Moron but even you are not qualified for that.

    Because You are a serial Liar. Yes I mean it

    Read your comments
    “Look at what happened at Pilkhana which was a RAW conspiracy. Look at what the Rakkhi Bahini did and this was also a RAW trained outfit. Even the Mujib Bahini which was a RAW trained group that committed atrocities in 1971 which was subsequently blamed on the Pakistan army.”

    Ans: These type of comments are simply to condemn Bangladesh.

    I am sorry to say some Black sheep like you were born in the country. To me ” You are disqualified to be Bangladeshi.”

    Now stay at your Pakistani blogs and make partnership with Taliban and Fanatics and your lord ISI.

  24. stingray says:

    I thought MB Munshi might be a wise guy but the last comment from him changed my thought. He is just a badly brain washed guy. Shame!

  25. Ronaldo The Great says:

    MBI MUNSHI,

    Here we took you lightly and respond you. So you have got chance to respond for your Garbage and Mellisa comments.
    You are not more than a Male ware.
    But every thing does have a limit and you are crossing your line about the Lie.
    I am happy that you have posted such comment and I Doc strange love and Its author have the highest amount of credibility . It does not matter what the guy like you think of that.

    But look before you leap. It is your good luck that you are a very small fish in an Ocean. so your comment does not have matter. But Just remember one thing for those serial lies if any legal action is taken over you from Bangladesh or India, Even your favorite Taliban can’t save you for Jail or fine. But you know Justice will think twice to send a Cheap guy like you to Jail .

  26. Rezwan says:

    I am surprised Mr. Munshi that you are denying a genocide and trying to create bedtime stories.

    The genocide of Pakistani army is well documented.:
    http://www.genocidebangladesh.org/?page_id=12

    Please give evidence of your fairy tale:

    “Even the Mujib Bahini which was a RAW trained group that committed atrocities in 1971 which was subsequently blamed on the Pakistan army.”

    The Mujib Bahini never made formal declaration of allegiance to the Mujibnagar government. They not only opposed Tajuddin, they were opposed to Osmany, Commander-in-Chief of the Mukti Bahini, as well. They were in limited numbers – only a couple of thousands. operated in a limited area only – four sectors near Indian border according to Banglapedia.

    While the Mukti Bahini was fighting on the border and inside Bangladesh, the Mujib Bahini was most of the time in reserve in their Dehradun camp.

    You are trying to tell that these people, not the 1 lakh strong Pakistani army killed millions of Bangladeshis all across Bangladesh? They killed their own people and no eyewitnesses? Nobody ever accused them when now the trial of war criminals is going on? If they are culprits let people frame them too.

    Stop spreading lies. You are sounding like the genocide deniers who are trying to polish Pakistani army’s image.

  27. Sajjad Jahir says:

    MBI Munshi is a sycophant of Paki brutes. This sort of people generally suffer from paranoid delusion. Sometimes extreme religiosity clouds their sense of judgment. It is apalling to find raised in a Western country people become so much Talibanized in their mindset. Sorry, as I was writing this someone just told me MBI Munshi is a product of Londonistan. The ghettoized mullatic Bangladeshi clan can produce more such Paki lovers. So we should not be surprised.

  28. MBI Munshi says:

    No what is the fuck is wrong with you Mash and these Indian dalals that have made this a fan club. Indian atrocities have been written about and documented by former RAW operatives such as Dr. Kalidas Baidya, Ashoka Raina, Gen. Uban and dozens of Bangladeshi writers. It is intellectual frauds and dalals like you who no longer have the ability to think independently (a fact that you all seem to consider a virtue)that still considers that the only war crimes were committed by the Pakistan army. RAW and the Mujib Bahini carried out assassinations on known leftist intellectuals who were against Indian domination and hegemony. Was not Zahir Raihan killed by the Indians? Many of these deaths were subsequently blamed on the Pakistan army. Shame on you for not even trying to uncover the truth and for trying to keep this hidden. Now the same atrocity has been committed by the Indians and their dalals at Pilkhana. This will not be disclosed by any one here because none of you have any shame or honour or love for the country. You want the Indians to keep fucking us but you all remain their prostitutes while the rest of us that have balls will continue to speak the truth. No one in Bangladesh beleiave your shit anymore anyway.

  29. Mash says:

    Go away troll.

  30. Ronaldo The Great says:

    None of Bangladesh ? MBI TALIBAN MUNSHI? You are a Pakistani Man. So don’t dare to consider yourself Bangladeshi.

    and Don’t come here

    • Mash says:

      I dont care where he is from. I have plenty of Pakistani friends and readers who are very welcome here, as is anyone else who is not a troll.

      But, this one is a troll. This troll has hijacked the thread. Though it was mildly amusing, I am actually pretty tired of it now. Hearing the same old thing about his greatness and his lunacy is getting nauseating. He has no shame. The more people laugh at him, the more he comes back.

      So, here’s what I will do. I have indulged him enough in his need to draw attention to himself on this blog that he cannot get for himself elsewhere.

      From now on, MBI Munshi is banned from commenting on this blog.

      So, go away troll. (I told you I’d get tired of you)

  31. Journey2Infinitive says:

    Munshi,

    Has Zahir Raihan told you this on Dream? So You know how Zahir Raihan was killed. So you must be taken to Remand to know actual truth although whole country knows he dedicated his life in 1971 for the country . Zahir Raihan family even does not believe your claim. But I think now as you are so much sure , you should be taken to court and you have to prove this.

    So be lunatic and go to Jail.

  32. Anthony L says:

    I have visited your website before. The more I take in, the more I keep coming back! ;-P

  33. As a brand new pet owner I welcome all the information and facts in this article. I want my new puppy to get very well trained and have a wholesome atmosphere to live in. Many thanks for the tips.

Comments are closed.